By Crossave · Updated: August 2026
A few years ago the choice was close to automatic: PSA for everything. In 2026 the Pokémon grading market is more divided — PSA is still the most recognised and the most liquid, but CGC has gained ground quickly (roughly a quarter of the market in 2025) and BGS remains the reference for anyone who wants maximum detail on vintage cards. Understanding the differences helps both when choosing where to send a card and when reading a grade on an already-slabbed listing you are comparing across sellers.
PSA is still the standard, with the largest share of the market (over 70%), and generally the easiest grade to resell anywhere in the world. A PSA 10 tends to command a higher resale premium — indicatively 20-30% more than a BGS or CGC of the same grade on the same card. On cost, be careful — this is the part that changes most often: on 2 June 2026 PSA SUSPENDED its four Value tiers — Value Bulk ($24.99), Value ($32.99), Value Plus ($49.99) and Value Max ($64.99) — to clear a backlog of millions of cards. The cheapest orderable tier today is Regular at $79.99 per card with a 50 business day turnaround, and the faster tiers cost considerably more. PSA has said it will reopen the paused tiers once the backlog clears, and has extended paid memberships for free in the meantime: if you are reading this months later, check whether they are orderable again. Either way, always check the current price list on psacard.com before you ship.
Besides the overall grade, BGS assigns four separate subgrades (centering, corners, edges, surface) of up to 10 points each — useful if you want to know exactly where a card loses points, not just the final number. The top tier, the Black Label (all four subgrades at 10), is particularly rare and sought after: on selected vintage cards it can be worth 4-6 times an ungraded copy, and can beat an equivalent PSA 10 by 15-40%. The Economy service starts at around $20 per card, with long turnaround times (80-100 business days).
CGC started out grading comics but has established itself firmly in trading card games too, with an Economy service starting indicatively between $17 and $20 per card (this price list has also changed more than once during 2026) and turnaround often comparable to BGS. The trade-off: in the Pokémon market a CGC card of the same grade still tends to be worth less than an equivalent PSA or BGS, although the gap is narrowing — PSA's price premium on modern cards has come down to roughly 5-10%.
There is no single right answer: PSA remains the safest choice if the goal is maximum liquidity and the highest resale price, BGS is worth it on vintage cards where the subgrade detail makes the difference, and CGC is the cheapest and quickest option if grading is mainly about certifying authenticity rather than maximising resale value.
When you compare prices of already-graded cards across sellers (on Crossave, for instance), the certification — PSA 10, BGS 9.5, CGC 9.5 and so on — is part of the price just as much as the card itself: two listings of the same card can differ wildly simply because one is a PSA 10 and the other a BGS 9. Put the exact grade in your search and Crossave shows only the listings that genuinely state that certification — not a different card, and not a different grade passed off as the same one.
Want the real total cost — duty and VAT included — for the product you're looking at?
Try the Crossave comparator →Sources checked for the figures in this guide: